Comparison

GEO tool or agency? How to choose

Robin DüblinPrices checked on 4 November 2026

A GEO tool such as Peec AI or Otterly fits if you can take over the analysis and the implementation yourself; an agency fits if you lack the time or the expertise for that. According to their pricing pages of 4 November 2026, tools cost between USD 29 and USD 489 a month, while agencies sell work rather than software and can only be compared by their scope.

Disclosure: Shortlisted sells a service and is therefore itself one side of this comparison. We have tried to describe both routes fairly, and at the end we say when we are not the right choice.

What a GEO tool does

A GEO tool (also called an AI visibility tool) puts a fixed list of questions to AI systems on a regular basis and counts how often your brand and your competitors are named. The best-known names in our measurement of 4 November 2026 were Peec AI (named in 25 of 99 answers), Otterly (19), Semrush (17), Profound (15) and Ahrefs (11).

Peec AI in detail, compared with Otterly.AI and Profound: Peec AI alternative for Swiss brands.

The tool delivers numbers, trends and often the cited sources. What it does not deliver: the decision on which page you change and how, and the change itself.

Tool and planPrice per monthScope according to pricing page
Peec AI StarterEUR 8550 prompts, choice of 3 AI models, daily tracking, 1 project
Peec AI ProEUR 205150 prompts, choice of 3 AI models, daily tracking, 2 projects
Peec AI AdvancedEUR 425350 prompts, choice of 3 AI models, daily tracking, 5 projects
Otterly.AI LiteUSD 2915 prompts, 4 search engines (ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot), daily tracking
Otterly.AI StandardUSD 189100 prompts, the same 4 search engines, daily tracking
Otterly.AI PremiumUSD 489400 prompts, the same 4 search engines, daily tracking

Sources: peec.ai/pricing and otterly.ai/pricing, both checked on 4 November 2026, prices with monthly payment. Otterly states 15 percent off for annual payment; Claude, Google AI Mode and Gemini cost extra there as add-ons. The pages do not say whether the prices include VAT. Prices change: check the pages yourself.

When a tool is the better choice

  • Someone on the team regularly reads analyses and adjusts pages, product data and sources.
  • You want to watch many questions, several markets or several brands every day.
  • You mainly want to know whether and how often you are named, and then decide for yourself.
  • You have more time than budget for outside work.

When an agency is the better choice

  • You lack the time or the expertise to turn measurements into page copy, product data and work on sources.
  • You want to know why AI names other brands and which websites are behind it, not just how often.
  • You want a counterpart who implements and measures again to a fixed plan.
  • You want questions in German and French with Swiss sources, without designing the questions yourself.

What agencies cost: examples with sources

Agency prices cannot be reduced to one number. We therefore only name prices that we could read on the provider's own website, each on 4 November 2026.

Provider and offerPriceSource
bulk branding, Radar: 20 customer questions, one-off measurementCHF 1,400 one-offbulk-branding.ch/geo-agentur-schweiz, prices without VAT according to the page
bulk branding, Boost: three measurements and all to-dosCHF 3,400 with checklist, from CHF 5,500 with implementation
bulk branding, Orbit: monthly measurementCHF 690 a month, at least 6 months
Shortlisted, auditCHF 1,490 one-offshortlisted.ch/#preise
Shortlisted, ongoing supportCHF 890 a month, cancellable every month

To show the spread: asked "How much does a GEO agency cost in Switzerland?", ChatGPT named CHF 1,500 to 8,000 a month on 4 November 2026, and Perplexity named CHF 300 to 900 for basic support. We have not checked these AI figures; they mainly show how far apart the statements are.

When Shortlisted is not the right choice

  • You have a team that analyses and implements. Then a tool is enough, and you save the agency fee.
  • You need daily, very broad measurement with hundreds of questions, several countries or many brands. Tools do that better than our monthly measurement.
  • You do not sell products online. So far we have only measured consumer brands with their own online shop: skincare and cosmetics, watches, jewellery, mattresses. We have no experience with consulting firms, B2B software or local service providers.
  • You want a broad agency for SEO, advertising and web design from one source. Our offer is narrowly focused on AI visibility.
  • You want a guaranteed mention or a place in the answer. Nobody can guarantee that, and neither can we.
  • You want calls in French. We hold calls in German or English; the analysis and report are also available in French.

Checklist: ten questions before you decide

  1. Which questions are measured, and can I set and check them myself?
  2. In which AI systems, in which languages and how often?
  3. Is each question asked several times? A single answer says little, because answers vary.
  4. Which number is reported: the share of answers that name my brand, or a score without explanation?
  5. Does the report show the sources behind the answers and who is named instead?
  6. Who implements, and what exactly is included in the price?
  7. How long is the contract term, and how do I cancel?
  8. Is there a dated baseline measurement and a re-measurement on a fixed schedule?
  9. Can I see the raw data and the list of questions?
  10. Is a placement or mention guaranteed? If so, that is a warning sign, because nobody controls what AI answers.

How we answer these questions is described in our method.

Our suggestion

If you are unsure, first have it measured what AI answers about your category today. Our free AI analysis shows that within 48 hours. After that you can decide whether a tool, an agency or both make sense. How we work as a GEO agency for SMEs and startups is described on a separate page; you can book a 20-minute call through the booking page.

Frequently asked questions

Does an SME need a GEO tool?

Only if someone on your team regularly reads the measurements and turns them into changes to pages and sources. A tool shows how often your brand is named. It does not change your website. Without a person who acts, you are left with numbers.

What does a GEO tool cost?

According to the pricing pages of 4 November 2026, Peec AI costs EUR 85, 205 or 425 a month (50, 150 or 350 prompts) and Otterly.AI USD 29, 189 or 489 a month (15, 100 or 400 prompts), each with monthly payment. On top comes your own working time.

What does a GEO agency cost?

That depends on the scope. Two published examples of 4 November 2026: bulk branding charges CHF 1,400 once for a measurement with 20 customer questions or CHF 690 a month, Shortlisted CHF 1,490 once for the audit or CHF 890 a month. The two offers are not built the same way.

Can an agency replace a tool?

In part. An agency also measures, but usually less often and with fewer questions than a tool that runs every day. In return it takes on the interpretation and the implementation. Some companies use both: a tool for ongoing monitoring, an agency for the work on the pages.

Sources